Wednesday, 30 April 2014

My Views on Hudud

Malaysia has once again been thrown into a political vortex and the credit this time goes to Parti Islam Se-Malaysia (PAS) who have expressed their intention to table a Private Member’s Bill in Parliament to provide for the enactment of a Syariah Criminal Offences (Hudud) Enactment in the Kelantan.

Before we go into the legality of the proposed Hudud Enactment, it is prudent for the position of Islam, vis-à-vis the Federal Constitution (FC) to be clarified and elucidated.

The Malaysian Constitution and the Position of Islam
Malaysia is neither a theocratic state nor it is a fully secular state like Turkey or India. I say this because the FC states that Islam is the religion of the Federation (Article 3) and also prohibits the propagation of non-Islamic doctrines amongst Muslims in Malaysia (Article 11(4)). Hence, Islam enjoys a protection within our constitutional framework that other religious groups do not, but it does not in any way place Islam above any other religion because Article 3 provides for an incontrovertible guarantee that “other religions (besides Islam) may be practised in peace and harmony in any part of the Federation.”

Our Constitution is secular and the best description our governance model is one that is secular based. A good example of a theocratic state would be Iran and the Iranian Constitution of 1979 unambiguously reinforces this. Article 1 of the Iranian Constitution of 1979 states that: “The form of government of Iran is that of an Islamic Republic” while Article 2 explains this to mean, among other things, “the necessity of submission [to Allah] and the “fundamental role” of “divine revelation” in “setting forth the laws.” While, article 56 states that “absolute sovereignty over the world and man belongs to God.”

A further example of an Islamic theocratic state is Maldives; in 2008, Maldives adopted a new constitution that states, inter alia, in order to be a citizen of Maldives, one has to profess the religion of Islam (Article 9(d)) and all laws have to be based on Islam and any law that is contrary to any tenet of Islam cannot be enacted in Maldives (Article 10(b)).

Malaysia’s constitution does not have such provisions hence I am baffled by the attempts of certain quarters who maintain that Malaysia is an Islamic state. A year after Independence, on 1 May 1958, then Prime Minister Tunku Abdul Rahman clarified in the Legislative Council that “I would like to make it clear that this country is not an Islamic state as it is generally understood. We merely provide that Islam shall be the official religion of the state.”

Again on his 80th Birthday, the Tunku reiterated “the country has a multi-racial population with various beliefs. Malaysia must continue as a secular state with Islam as the official religion.”

Malaysia is a fully functional secular-based constitutional monarchy with Islam as the religion of the Federation. In coming to this assertion, I am aided by the decision of the Supreme Court of Malaysia in the case of Che Omar bin Che Soh v Public Prosecutor (1988), that the term “Islam” in Article 3(1) of the Federal Constitution meant “only such acts as relate to rituals and ceremonies… the law in this country is … secular law.”

Secular Laws for a Multi-Religious Country
Malaysia enjoys a sterling tradition as a multi-religious country. For centuries Muslims, Buddhists, Christians, Hindus and others have lived in peace and harmony. However, disputes over the usage of the term “Allah” by Christians to refer to God in the Bahasa Malaysia version of their Bibles and the confiscation of Bahasa Malaysia Bibles in Selangor has indeed put a strain on the strong and durable relationships between the various religious groups in Malaysia.

Our criminal laws and criminal justice system is secular and must remain secular because any attempt to change this would be tantamount to dismembering the basic structure of our constitution. The doctrine of basic structure finds its origins in the Indian Supreme Court decision in the case of Keshvanand Bharti v. State of Kerala (1973). The Indian Supreme Court “struck a bridle path by holding that in the exercise of the power conferred by Art. 368 (the article that lays down the procedure for amending the Indian Constitution), the Parliament cannot amend the Constitution so as to damage or destroy the basic structure of the Constitution.” Employing the sagacious logic of the Indian Supreme Court, I would argue that the Federal parliament or any State Legislature cannot pass any law that will alter the basic structure of our FC. The Federal Court must also be ready to exercise its powers as the defender of the FC and unwind any attempt to alter the basic structure of our country.

The administration of the criminal justice system and the powers to enactment criminal laws is clearly the purview of the Federal Government (List I, 9th Schedule of the FC). Part 4 (e)(ii) of List 1, 9th Schedule states that :
“Civil and criminal law and procedure and the administration of justice, including—
(e) subject to paragraph (ii), the following:
(i) contract; partnership, agency and other special contracts; master and servant; inns and inn-keepers; actionable wrongs; property and its transfer and hypothecation, except land; bona vacantia; equity and trusts; marriage, divorce and legitimacy; married women’s property and status; interpretation of federal law; negotiable instruments; statutory declarations; arbitration; mercantile law; registration of businesses and business names; age of majority; infants and minors; adoption; succession, testate and intestate; probate and letters of administration; bankruptcy and insolvency; oaths and affirmations; limitation; reciprocal enforcement of judgments and orders; the law of evidence;
(ii) the matters mentioned in paragraph (i) do not include islamic personal law relating to marriage, divorce, guardianship, maintenance, adoption, legitimacy, family law, gifts or succession, testate and intestate.”

Hence no state can pass any criminal laws because the constitution does not allow it even if it is a set of Islamic criminal laws and there must always be uniformity of laws. Article 75 of the FC unambiguously states that in the event there is any conflict between a federal and state law, federal law will prevail.

Hudud is also inconstant with Article 8 of the FC, the equality article, because we cannot have Muslims subjected to one form of punishment and non-Muslims subject to another form of punishment. The case of Hudud, those convicted of theft will have their limbs amputated but under our present, secular, criminal justice system, those convicted of theft will have to serve a custodial sentence.

Furthermore, how we will the authorities seek to investigate and charge a suspect when they are two sets of criminal laws when the assailant is a Muslim and the victim a non-Muslim or vice-versa. Furthermore, non-Muslims by law do not have to appear before any Syariah Court because it has no jurisdictions over non-Muslims. These sticky jurisdictional issues must be also factored into consideration to avoid a repeat the legal imbroglio that has followed the amendment to Article 121 of the FC.

While some have argued that Hudud an entity of Islam hence it should be come under the State’s List (List II, 9th Schedule) it is important to note that the State’s List on grants powers to State Legislatures to enact laws “1. Except with respect to the Federal territories of Kuala Lumpur, Labuan and Putrajaya, Islamic law and personal and family law of persons professing the religion of Islam, including the Islamic law relating to succession, testate and intestate, betrothal, marriage, divorce, dower, maintenance, adoption, legitimacy, guardianship, gifts, partitions and non-charitable trusts; wakafs and the definition and regulation of charitable and religious trusts, the appointment of trustees and the incorporation of persons in respect of Islamic religious and charitable endowments, institutions, trusts, charities and charitable institutions operating wholly within the State; Malay customs; Zakat, Fitrah and Baitulmal or similar Islamic religious revenue; mosques or any Islamic public place of worship, creation and punishment of offences by persons professing the religion of Islam against precepts of that religion, except in regard to matters included in the Federal List; the constitution, organization and procedure of Syariah courts, which shall have jurisdiction only over persons professing the religion of Islam and in respect only of any of the matters included in this paragraph, but shall not have jurisdiction in respect of offences except in so far as conferred by federal law; the control of propagating doctrines and beliefs among persons professing the religion of Islam; the determination of matters of Islamic law and doctrine and Malay custom.” Hence, there is no provision for any enactment of criminal laws, whether Islamic or otherwise, by any state legislature because the administration of the criminal justice system is part of the Federal List.

Conclusion
I have no intention into wading into the beliefs of any religions, every religion possess its own system of laws in varying degrees but as a matter of principle and to safeguard the supremacy and integrity of the Federal Constitution, we must strive to defend our secular nature.

Any form of theocratic criminal law is anathema to our long standing tradition of religious harmony because given the significant number of issues that already seeks to divides us and dividing us further on the basis of religion will be the most painful of all. I would dare say that an unbridled push for Hudud may even lead to the balkanisation of Malaysia on the basis of religious lines.

All politicians must think and act as Malaysians, with the welfare of all Malaysians on their mind and oppose any attempt to enact Hudud laws. I am proud that my party has made a clear and unequivocal stand on the matter. We are not opposed to any religion but we are compelled to defend the integrity of the Federal Constitution and our diverse way of life. It also does not augur well for the resounding minority in this country if the majority imposes their way on life on them, whether directly or indirectly.


The writer is the Executive Director of SEDAR Institute and a member of the Youth Central Committee, Parti Gerakan Rakyat Malaysia. The views expressed is solely his own.

Monday, 21 April 2014

The Constitutional Series: Understanding the Secular Nature of our Constitution

The Malayan (later Malaysian) Constitution was a product of a historical bargain between the Bumiputeras and the non-Bumiputeras. In essence, the bargain which some have termed the social contract provided for the granting of citizenship to the non-Bumiputeras and in return the Bumiputeras will enjoy a special status within our constitutional framework and Islam would be recognised as the religion of the Federation.

The obsession with this bargain or social contract has resulted in many political skirmishes and it has only served to raise the political temperature in Malaysia. But, a second and more fundamental aspect of our constitution is constantly overlooked, that is the basic structure of our constitution.

Understanding the Dual Legal System

Malaysia has a dual legal system, the civil law and the Syariah law. Civil law here issued to mean the system of law as passed by the legislature, including the common law and rules of equity embodied in the decisions of the courts. Syariah law on the other hand means Islamic law passed by the State Legislatures and, for the Federal Territories, Islamic law passed by Parliament. The scope of Islamic law applicable in Malaysia is laid down in paragraph 1 of the State List in the Federal Constitution[i]

However, in analysing our constitutional structure, we must understand the history behind the dual system. Before the British came to the Malay States, as Peninsular Malaysia was then known, the sultans in each of their respective States were the heads not only of the religion of Islam but were also the political leaders in their States. The applicable laws then were the Syariah law and customary law. The sultans were regarded as God’s vicegerent and were entrusted to run the States in accordance with the law ordained by Islam. The earliest record of Islamic law being practiced in the Malay States dates back to the early 14th century. Through a series of treaties with the Sultans and the numerous advice given by the British Residents, the role of the Sultans was redefined and their powers were confined to personal laws and customs. The rulers were regarded as a sovereign within his territory and ceased to be regarded as God’s vicegerent on earth. In so doing, the system of governance was turned into a secular institution as opposed to one based on Syariah as it originally was.[ii]

The colonization of the Malay States saw the importation of English law and the relegation of Islamic law to a narrower sphere of personal law. With the introduction of English law as the basic law via the Charters of Justice, particularly the Charter of Justice 1826, Islamic law was confined to personal laws and customs of local Malays and other Muslims. The role of Islamic law in the public sphere was thus curtailed. The application of English law in Malaysia is as stated in sections 3 and 5 of the Civil Law Act 1956.[iii]

The inclusion of Article 3 into the FC did not affect the civil rights of the non-Muslims to profess and practice their religion and this was stated clearly in the Reid Commission report.

The Basic Structure Doctrine and the Federal Constitution of Malaysia (FC)

It is safe to assume that drafting a constitution requires a degree of sophistication and assiduity. VR Krishna Iyer, in his book A Constitutional Miscellany (2003) stated that while a constitution is clearly not infallible, its basic structure cannot be overlooked because a power to amend will also include a power to repeal.

The doctrine was pronounced by the Indian Supreme Court in the case of Keshvanand Bharti v. State of Kerala. The Indian Supreme Court “struck a bridle path by holding that in the exercise of the power conferred by Art. 368 (the article that lays down the procedure for amending the Indian Constitution), the Parliament cannot amend the Constitution so as to damage or destroy the basic structure of the Constitution.

I would argue that another component that forms the basic structure of our Federal Constitution is the secular nature of our country I accept that we are not a secular state in the way India or Turkey is because Article 3 of the FC states that Islam is the religion of the Federation.

It is right to assume that the Reid Commission when drafting our Federal Constitution made every attempt to ensure it was close to perfection and ensured that there were no ambiguities and all aspects were covered in the Constitution. In order to retain the values of our country as well as ascertain development of human personality, certain provisions of the constitution must be kept on a high pedestal. These provisions, rights vested in the people, values, ideas, the granting of citizenship, the position of the rulers etc is the essence of our Constitution hence it forms the Basic Structure of the Constitution.

A closer evaluation of Article 3 will lead one to discover that the word “official” has been omitted and this is of significant constitutional value. The framers of our constitution, especially Justice Abdul Hamid felt there was a need to recognise the role of Islam in shaping Malaya. But the Reid Commission added a proviso in Article 3 of the FC that clearly stated that “but other religions may be practised in peace and harmony in any part of the Federation.” Article 3 is merely declaratory, acknowledging the historical position of Islam vis-à-vis Malaya and the balanced wording of Article 3 does not seek to elevate Islam over non-Islamic doctrines.

In fact, a more robust article that places Islam in a special position within our constitutional framework is in fact Article 11(4) that restricts the propagation of non-Islamic doctrines to Muslims in Malaysia and empowers the states to enact state laws with punitive powers to punish anyone who falls foul of Article 11(4).

Hence, a Malaysian constitutional scholar cannot deny that Malaysia is not a secular state but neither an Islamic theocratic state in the mould of Iran or Maldives. Malaysia is at best a hybrid state with a strong secular nature given our religious diversity.

The “Allah” Debate: A case study

A true test of our secular nature has been the debate over the usage of the Arabic term for God i.e. “Allah.” According to the Merdeka Centre, 77% of Muslims in Malaysia feel that the term “Allah” is the sole provenance of Muslims in Malaysia.

In fact many Malaysians are not aware that Christians, especially those in East Malaysia, have been using the term “Allah” to refer to God in the Bahasa Malaysia Bible known as the Al-Kitab. Even, Sikhs like me use the term “Allah” to refer to God in our holy scripture.

However, the dispute resulted in a High Court decision in 2009 that reversed the ban placed by the Home Minister on the usage of the term “Allah” in the Bahasa Malaysia version of the Herald, which is a weekly newsletter published by the Catholic Church in Malaysia. in October 2013, the Court of Appeal reversed the decision of the High Court and made a number of far reaching findings, chief amongst them, that the term “Allah” is not central to the Christian faith and the state has unfettered discretion in determining what is and what is not a threat to national security.

I find it odd and unorthodox; that a panel of three judges could decide on a theological matter and come to a conclusion on what is central and not central to the Christian faith. Theological debates fester up till today, for example the Sunni and Shia schism in Islam or the Catholic and Orthodox schism in Christianity. No secular authority, in the case the Malaysian Court of Appeal, should attempt to make a finding of fact on the centrality of any doctrine or terminology to any faith.

Herein lays the great threat to our secular nature, because the judges are the arbiters of justice and they hold great power in any democratic system. Judges in Malaysia however have enjoyed being subservient to the Executive and the Legislature, and have failed to defend and assert their autonomy as guaranteed by the FC.

Also, judges must judge in a vacuum without appealing to their preferences or prejudices. Judges cannot act in a way that is contrary to the basic structure of our constitution. In Herald case, the judges fell short of the standard expected of them when they elected to impose a Muslim standard on non-Muslims because they relied heavily on the Muslim ambivalence over the use of the word by non-Muslims to justify the reversal of the High Court verdict.

While I accept Article 11(4) of the FC gives the court’s much room to restrict propagation of non-Islamic amongst Muslims in Malaysia, any attempt by Christians to use the term “Allah” to convert Muslims in Malaysia would have fallen foul of the state enactments restricting the propagation to Muslims and action can be taken against such provocateurs. However, just because there is a possibility of this happening, Article 11(4) of the FC could not be used to ban Christians from using the world altogether because there already exist an efficacious system of state enactments to give effect to Article 11(4) of the FC and protect the Muslims in Malaysia. The civil rights of the Bahasa Malaysia speaking Christians must also be taken into account and there has been total neglect for the concerns of the Bahasa Malaysia speaking Christians. Hence, the failure of the courts to balance the rights of the all Malaysians points to a lack of appreciation of the basic structure of our constitution.

It does not augur well for the resounding minority in this country is the courts and its officers adopt position that is inconsonant with our constitutional framework. It is therefore a continuing challenge for our judicial system to ensure that it functions effectively and without fear or favour.

The judiciary being the final and only avenue open to individuals who seek to enforce the fundamental liberties guaranteed to them under the Federal Constitution must not forsake nor abdicate their duty to preserve, protect and defend the Constitution and we must remain vigilant against any attempt to unravel our secular nature given our diverse make up.



[i] “Legislating Faith In Malaysia,” Nurjaanah Abdullah @ Chew Li Hua, Singapore Journal of Legal Studies
[2007] 264–289
[ii] See Ahmad Mohamed Ibrahim, “The Administration of Islamic Law in Malaysia,” (Kuala Lumpur: Institute of Islamic Understanding Malaysia, 2000).
[iii] Supra, n. i